What point does Friedman seek to illustrate with his descriptions of Bangalore, India, and Dalian, China, in his book?
Okay, this is a fascinating question. When Thomas Friedman mentions Bangalore and Dalian in his book The World Is Flat, he's essentially using these two highly vivid and representative examples to illustrate his core thesis to the average reader: Globalization has entered a whole new phase, where technology has "flattened" the world, enabling people from different countries and regions to collaborate and compete on the same stage.
Here’s how to understand it:
First, What Does "The World Is Flat" Mean?
Before diving into these two cities, we need a quick overview of what Friedman means by "The World Is Flat."
Imagine long ago, if you wanted to do business with someone in America, you needed ships and telegrams—it was difficult and costly. The world was like a planet full of mountains and canyons, with enormous barriers to communication and cooperation.
But now? Thanks to the internet, fiber optics, and various software applications, we can have video conferences and transfer files with someone on the other side of the planet almost instantly and at near-zero cost. It's like a magical force that has bulldozed the mountains and canyons on Earth's surface. Geographical location is no longer a barrier. Anyone with talent and an internet connection can participate in the global division of labor and collaboration.
Bangalore and Dalian are two prime examples of places propelled onto the world stage by this force.
Bangalore: The "Global Back Office" Serving the English-Speaking World
Friedman calls Bangalore the "Perfect Storm Center of a flattened world." Why?
- Software Outsourcing Hub: You've probably heard that many US companies outsource their IT work, software development, and even customer service calls to India. Bangalore is the epicenter of this. A US bank's backend data processing or software maintenance might be handled by an engineering team working out of an office building in Bangalore overnight (capitalizing on the time zone differential).
- Language and Talent Advantage: India has a vast pool of English-speaking, well-educated engineers and technical professionals whose salaries are significantly lower than their US counterparts.
- What It Illustrates: Bangalore shows us that in a "flat" world, intellectual work can be packaged, transported, and traded just like physical goods. Previously, we thought only tangible products like clothes or toys could be made in China or Vietnam and sold in the US. Now, "brain work" like coding, design, and data analysis can similarly be "outsourced" from the US to India via an internet cable.
A Simple Analogy: It's like having a burst pipe at home. Before, you could only call a local plumber. Now, you can use an app to find the best-reviewed and most reasonably priced plumber, even if they live on the other side of the city. They might guide you remotely or send a robot to fix it. Bangalore is that "best-reviewed, reasonably priced" remote team of IT plumbers.
Dalian: The "Another Bangalore" Serving the East Asian World
If you've heard the Bangalore story, why does Friedman specifically highlight Dalian, China?
This is to illustrate that this "flattening" trend is not unique to India; it's a global phenomenon with different regional variants.
- Outsourcing Hub for Japan and South Korea: Dalian, much like Bangalore, is a center for software and IT services outsourcing. Its defining feature, however, is that it primarily serves Japan and South Korea, not the US.
- Unique Language and Cultural Advantage: Due to historical and geographical ties, Dalian possesses a large pool of Japanese and Korean language talent. Companies from Japan and South Korea find that outsourcing tasks like software development and data processing to Dalian is not only cheaper but also often involves smoother communication than outsourcing to India or the US.
- What It Illustrates: Dalian's case strongly reinforces Friedman's point. It proves:
- Flattening is Everywhere: It's not just the English-speaking world that has been "flattened"; the Japanese and Korean-speaking worlds have undergone the same process.
- Different Cities Find Their Niche: Different cities leverage their unique advantages (like language proficiency and cultural affinity) to find their place on the flat world stage. Bangalore captures US-based work, while Dalian captures Japanese and Korean contracts. They both operate on the same "flat" planet, but enter the game through different pathways.
To Summarize
Friedman specifically paired these two cities to demonstrate a clear logic:
- Core Thesis: Technology (especially the internet) has flattened the world, creating a global competitive arena.
- Bangalore's Example: Proves that "brain work" can be outsourced; US jobs can be "taken" by engineers in India. This is the classic manifestation of the "flat world."
- Dalian's Example: Proves the phenomenon is global; it's not only achievable by India. China is also actively participating, finding its unique niche catering to Japan and South Korea.
In essence, Friedman uses these vivid examples, particularly to tell readers in developed nations: Wake up! Your future competitors may not be the rival company down the street, but quite possibly a young person you've never met from Bangalore or Dalian. On this flat planet, everyone stands on the same starting line.