Why do different people interpret the same Tarot card differently?

Answer (2)
Leonard Nichols
Leonard Nichols
Experienced astrologer, 10+ years practice.

That's an excellent question, and one that many people are confused by. Let me use a simple analogy to help you understand:

Think of Tarot cards like a movie packed with information or a song rich in meaning.

Imagine you and a friend watch the same movie. Will your impressions be exactly the same afterward? Probably not.

  • You might focus on the protagonists' love story and find it deeply moving.
  • Your friend might be more interested in the suspenseful plot, thinking the director's foreshadowing was brilliant.
  • A third person might even believe the film's soundtrack and cinematography were its greatest strengths.

You watched the exact same movie, so why are your feelings and interpretations so different?

It's because each of you has different life experiences, personalities, current concerns, and even focuses on different details while watching. Your 'perspective' on the movie is different.

Tarot interpretation works on the exact same principle. A card laid out is like that movie; it inherently contains a wealth of information, symbolism, and possibilities. Different interpreters are like different viewers, and they will 'see' different things for the following reasons:

1. Different Knowledge Bases and Life Experiences ("Different Professional Backgrounds for Film Critics")

Some interpreters might have extensive knowledge of mythology or psychology. When they see 'The High Priestess' card, they might associate it with a Greek goddess or Jungian psychology's 'anima' archetype, leading to an interpretation focused on spiritual growth and the subconscious. Another interpreter, with rich life experience and a history of complex relationships, might intuitively feel that 'The High Priestess' represents a situation of 'outward calm, inner secrets.' Both interpretations are valid; they simply approach it from different angles.

2. Different Points of Connection for Intuition and 'Inspiration' ("Which Scene Touches You Most")

Tarot interpretation isn't just about memorizing card meanings; it heavily relies on the interpreter's intuition. When the cards are laid out, the interpreter's intuition acts like an antenna, seeking the most 'spark-filled' connection between the card imagery, your question, and your current state.

For instance, upon seeing the 'Three of Swords' (three swords piercing a heart), one interpreter might intuitively feel it represents past wounds subtly aching. Another might intuitively tell you it's a 'difficult but necessary decision you have to make.' Both interpretive directions stem from the core meaning of 'heartache,' but the paths they suggest are entirely different, depending on which possibility the interpreter's intuition 'illuminates.'

3. Different Focus and Interpretation Styles ("Do You Want a Film Review or a Plot Summary?")

Every interpreter has their own style.

  • Some are very practical, preferring to offer 'what to do' advice. Seeing the 'Eight of Wands,' they might say: "Act fast! Don't hesitate!"
  • Others focus on spiritual healing. Seeing the same card, they might say: "Your inner thoughts are rapidly taking shape; pay attention to the feelings this process brings you."
  • Still others prefer a spiritual growth perspective, perhaps saying: "This is a period of accelerated energy flow; the universe is urging you forward."

You see, they all convey a sense of 'speed,' but the feelings and insights they offer you are completely different.

In summary:

So, different interpretations of the same card by different people don't mean someone is right and someone is wrong, nor does it mean Tarot cards are 'inaccurate.'

On the contrary, this is precisely the charm of Tarot. It's not a machine that gives standard answers, but rather a kaleidoscope. It projects your question, your state, and the card's symbolism all together, and each interpreter, from their most skilled and perceptive angle, interprets this complex and beautiful interplay of light and shadow for you.

Therefore, finding a Tarot reader is essentially finding an interpretive 'viewer' who is 'on your wavelength' and can offer you an insightful perspective. What's important isn't which interpretation is the 'most correct,' but rather which interpretation is most useful and resonant for you right now.

Kathryn Howe
Kathryn Howe
Mystic, specializing in divination arts.

Hello, that's an excellent question, and it's one that many friends new to Tarot cards often have.

You can imagine Tarot cards as a very skilled "mute storyteller." They have so much they want to say, but exactly what they say and how they say it largely depends on the listener (the reader) and the person asking the question.

This is mainly due to several reasons:

  1. The reader is a "translator," not a "repeater." Each Tarot card contains a wealth of symbols and meanings, like a compressed information package. For example, "The Lovers" card can represent a beautiful romance, or it might signify an important "choice." The reader's job is like that of a translator; they need to interpret the most fitting meaning of that card in the current context, based on your specific question, clues from other cards in the spread, and their own experience and intuition. Every translator has a different knowledge background, life experience, and linguistic style, so the "flavor" of their translation will naturally vary. Experienced readers can see deeper, more detailed aspects, while a novice might only be able to state the most superficial meaning from a book.

  2. The question acts as a "filter," determining which aspect is seen. The same card can yield vastly different answers depending on the question asked. For instance, you draw "The Tower" card. If your question is, "Should I change jobs?", it might be warning you that your current company is about to undergo drastic changes (like layoffs or collapse), urging you to leave quickly. But if your question is, "How is my relationship with my partner?", it might mean you're about to have a sudden, major argument that shatters the current peace. Therefore, the question itself sets a scope and direction for the card's interpretation.

  3. The reader's personal style and intuition. This aspect is a bit more mystical, but it certainly exists. Tarot interpretation isn't entirely rational logical analysis; much of it relies on the reader's intuition. In the moment of reading, a certain image or symbol might suddenly "jump out," leading the reader to a particular association that perfectly corresponds to your current predicament. It's like two painters painting the same landscape; because their state of mind and focus are different, the final artworks will have completely different feelings.

In summary, Tarot cards are not a "1+1=2" mathematical formula; they are more like an interactive tool, a mirror. They reflect a unique image created by the combination of "your question" and "the reader's interpretation." So, it's perfectly normal for different people to interpret the same card and arrive at different conclusions. The key isn't who is right or wrong, but which interpretation resonates most with you and offers you insight and reflection.