Religious Impact: How would the confirmed existence of extraterrestrial intelligent life impact the doctrines of major world religions and human philosophical views?

Molly Archer
Molly Archer
Expert in ancient Greek philosophy.

This question is incredibly fascinating, like throwing a giant rock into a calm lake, with ripples spreading to every corner of our thoughts. If one day the news truly announced, "We have found extraterrestrial intelligent life," the impact on humanity would undoubtedly be nuclear-level. I'll try to discuss my views in plain language, from both religious and philosophical perspectives.


I. Religion: God's Grand Design Needs an Update

Major religions are like operating systems "custom-made" for humanity. The appearance of aliens would be akin to a sudden emergence of an intelligent species using a completely different operating system; the system would need patching, or even a complete reinstallation.

1. Abrahamic Religions (Christianity, Islam, Judaism): The Biggest Challenge, Requiring a "Major Patch"

These religions share a common characteristic: anthropocentrism.

  • The Status of "Chosen Ones" Undermined: The Bible states that God created man in His own image. What about aliens? Are they God's "other designs"? Are we still His most special creation? Once this uniqueness is shattered, the very foundation of faith would be severely impacted.
  • The "Scope of Salvation" Problem: The core of Christianity is Jesus' atonement for humanity's sins. The question then arises: Do aliens have "original sin"? Do they need to be saved? Is Jesus' salvation an "Earth-limited edition" or a "universe-wide version"? If every intelligent planet requires a savior, how many "Holy Sons" would there be in the universe?
  • Interpretation of Scriptures: Clergy and theologians would be extremely busy. They would re-interpret scriptures, perhaps arguing that "man" mentioned in the Bible or Quran broadly refers to all "intelligent life," or that God's creation far exceeds human imagination, and the scriptures are merely a "beginner's guide" for Earthlings.

A fitting analogy: This is similar to when Copernicus proposed the heliocentric model; the Church initially vehemently opposed it because it challenged the notion of "Earth being the center of the universe." But what happened in the end? Religion survived by reinterpreting and adapting. This time will be no different; mainstream religions will strive to incorporate aliens into their theological frameworks, but the process will undoubtedly be painful and controversial. Some extreme fundamentalist factions might directly denounce aliens as "demons" or a "hoax."

2. Eastern Religions (Buddhism, Hinduism, Taoism): Less Impact, More Like an "Aha! Moment"

In contrast, Eastern religions possess a much grander "cosmology," making them more readily compatible with the existence of extraterrestrial life.

  • Buddhism: Buddhism long ago introduced the concept of "three thousand great chiliocosms" (or "trichiliocosm"), positing countless worlds in the universe inhabited by various life forms (devas, asuras, humans, hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals – the "six realms of existence"). Aliens? They might simply be "humans" from another world, or a type of "deva" we haven't encountered. Their appearance would, in fact, corroborate the Buddhist scriptures' descriptions of the universe's vastness. All sentient beings are equal, and Buddhist teachings offer universal salvation; aliens, too, can practice and attain Buddhahood.
  • Hinduism: In Hindu mythology, the universe undergoes cyclical creation and destruction, with countless universes (Brahmanda) containing various gods, demons, demigods, and beings. Extraterrestrial intelligent life could easily be seen as part of this vast cosmic system, nothing particularly surprising.
  • Taoism: The core of Taoist thought is "Tao follows nature" (道法自然). The "Tao" is the ultimate law of the universe, giving birth to all things. The emergence of other intelligent life in the universe perfectly aligns with the "Tao's" infinite possibilities and creativity. It's simply a part of "nature."

Therefore, for Eastern religions, this would be more of a "confirmation of worldview" rather than a subversion.


II. Philosophy: Our "Place" in the Universe Reset

If religion is about "belief," then philosophy is about "thought." The appearance of aliens would force us to re-examine three ultimate questions: Who are we? Where do we come from? Where are we going?

1. Humanity No Longer the "Sole Protagonist"

We are accustomed to being the only intelligent species on Earth, the "crown of creation." This Human Exceptionalism is the psychological cornerstone of our entire civilization.

  • The Definition of Intelligence Rewritten: Our intelligence, morality, and art might just be a "local dialect" of intelligence. Aliens might possess modes of thought we cannot comprehend (e.g., collective consciousness, non-linear time perception). This would humble us, making us realize that we are not the sole measure of all things in the universe.
  • The End of Solitude and a New Solitude: On one hand, we would no longer be solitary thinkers in the universe, which might bring immense comfort. But on the other hand, if alien civilizations are far more advanced than us, we might experience a new, deeper sense of loneliness—like ants facing humans, unable to communicate, unable to understand, only able to look up in awe.

2. The Ultimate Test of Morality and Ethics

How would we treat aliens? This would become a mirror, reflecting the true nature of our civilization.

  • "Dark Forest" Theory or "Cosmic Family"? Would we treat them as potential threats (like in The Three-Body Problem), or as equal partners? This would spark a global ethical debate. Our ways of treating other species and different ethnic groups on Earth might be magnified to an interstellar scale.
  • "Human Rights" Need to Upgrade to "Intelligent Life Rights": Our legal and moral systems are built around "humans." In the future, we might need a set of universal ethics applicable to all intelligent life.

3. The Meaning of Civilization's Existence

  • Hope or Warning from the "Great Filter" Theory: Astronomers have a "Great Filter" hypothesis, which suggests that there are almost insurmountable obstacles on the path of life evolving into an interstellar civilization. If we discover aliens, especially civilizations older than us, it would imply that we might have already crossed the "filter," and the future is full of hope. However, if we only find ruins of civilizations, that would be a terrifying warning for our own future.
  • A New Common Goal: Facing a common "other," internal conflicts among nations, states, and races on Earth might seem insignificant. As depicted in sci-fi films, the appearance of aliens could unite humanity like never before, forming a true "community of shared future for Earth." This might be the greatest opportunity to advance our civilization.

Conclusion: A Civilization's "Coming-of-Age Ceremony"

All in all, confirming the existence of extraterrestrial intelligent life would be a "coming-of-age ceremony" for human civilization.

It would bring chaos, fear, and a crisis of faith, but simultaneously usher in unprecedented humility, unity, and self-reflection. We would be forced to step out of our self-centered cradle, and for the first time, truly examine ourselves and our world as "members of the cosmos."

This process would undoubtedly be painful, but also a great leap forward. It's like a child realizing for the first time that their home isn't the whole world, and there are vast cities, countries, and planets outside. They might feel lost, but they will ultimately grow because of it.