What is "Active Surveillance" or "Active Monitoring"? Which Patients Are Suitable?

Okay, no problem. Let's talk about "active surveillance" in plain language to help you make sense of it.

---

What is "Active Surveillance" or "Watchful Waiting"? Which Patients Are Suitable?

Hey there. When you or a family member gets a thyroid cancer diagnosis, the first reaction is probably, "Oh my god, it's cancer! We need surgery to remove it ASAP!" That's completely normal. But for certain types of thyroid cancer, doctors might suggest something that sounds a bit "counterintuitive": "How about we don't rush into surgery and just monitor it regularly for now?"

This is what we're talking about today: Active Surveillance, also called Watchful Waiting.

1. What is "Active Surveillance"? Does it mean ignoring the cancer?

Absolutely not ignoring it!

Think of "active surveillance" like this:

You find a small, seemingly harmless anthill in your yard. Instead of immediately dousing it with pesticide, you decide to watch it first. Every so often, you check: Is the anthill getting bigger? Is it starting to head towards the house? As long as it stays put and doesn't cause trouble, you can "peacefully coexist" with it. But you keep the pesticide ready; the moment you see any sign of it "misbehaving," you can deal with it immediately.

That's the principle behind "active surveillance." It's not "giving up on treatment"; it's a "delayed treatment" strategy. Specifically, it involves:

• No immediate surgery: Temporarily avoiding interventions like surgery or radiation therapy.
• Regular monitoring: Closely watching the tumor through very regular check-ups (primarily neck ultrasounds and some blood tests).
• Ready to intervene: Setting clear "action" thresholds. If monitoring shows the tumor has grown significantly or shows signs of spreading, standard treatment (usually surgery) is initiated immediately.

2. Why can thyroid cancer be "watched"? Isn't it cancer?

This is a key question. Because not all cancers are equally "aggressive."

Many thyroid cancers, especially the most common papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC), are particularly "lazy," earning it the nickname "indolent cancer". Its characteristics are:

• Very slow growth: It might not change size for years, even over a decade.
• Low risk of spread: Especially for very small tumors, the chance of distant spread (metastasis) is extremely low.
• Excellent prognosis: Even after surgery, the cure rate is very high.

It's precisely because of this "lazy" nature that we have the confidence to "watch" it. Research shows that for many patients with small papillary thyroid microcarcinomas (PTMC, diameter ≤1cm), the vast majority of tumors show no progression under long-term observation. Only a very small number eventually require surgery, and delaying surgery does not affect the final treatment outcome.

3. Which patients are suitable for "Active Surveillance"? (Key Points!)

While "active surveillance" is a good option, it's definitely not for everyone. It has very strict selection criteria. Doctors will act like detectives, thoroughly evaluating both the "tumor" and the "patient."

1. First, assess how "well-behaved" your tumor is:

• Size is key: Usually requires a diameter ≤1.0 cm "microcarcinoma" (PTMC). This is one of the most important prerequisites.
• Location matters: The tumor cannot be in a dangerous spot. For example, it shouldn't be right next to the trachea, esophagus, or pressing against the recurrent laryngeal nerve (which controls your voice). If the location is unfavorable, even a small tumor might warrant earlier surgery.
• No "suspicious features": Ultrasound shows the tumor has clear boundaries, no signs of invasion into surrounding tissues, and no evidence of spread to neck lymph nodes.
• Pathology type: A biopsy must clearly confirm papillary thyroid carcinoma. If it's a more aggressive type (like medullary or anaplastic carcinoma), waiting is absolutely not an option.

2. Second, assess your personal situation:

• Good psychological resilience: This is crucial! You need to be able to accept the fact that you have "cancer in your body" without becoming overly anxious or letting it disrupt your normal life. If it causes constant worry, sleepless nights, or affects your well-being, surgery might be the better choice for peace of mind.
• High compliance: You must be a "compliant" patient, able to strictly adhere to the doctor's schedule for follow-up appointments. If you can't commit to regular monitoring, the whole point of "surveillance" is lost, and the risk increases significantly.
• Age and overall health: Active surveillance is an excellent option for older patients or those with other serious health conditions (like heart or lung disease) who may not tolerate surgery well.

4. Benefits and Challenges of "Active Surveillance"

Final Thoughts

"Active surveillance" reflects medical progress. It shows us that fighting cancer doesn't always mean "eliminating it at all costs." Sometimes, "peaceful coexistence" is also a wise strategy.

But this is absolutely not a "one-size-fits-all" decision. It requires deep discussion between you and your doctor. Lay out all the pros and cons, then make the choice best suited to you – considering your specific condition, your personality, and your lifestyle.

If you meet the criteria and feel mentally prepared, "active surveillance" could be an excellent option, allowing you to maintain a high quality of life while ensuring safety.