Rumors Cease with the Wise, Yet Why Do the Wise Often Fall for Rumors in Reality?

Hello, that's an excellent question because it punctures a very common assumption we often hold. The saying "Rumors stop with the wise" sounds incredibly reasonable, but reality often slaps us in the face.

The truth is, so-called "wise people" are also human, not perfectly rational computers. The reasons they can also be deceived are quite complex. Let me break it down for you in plain language:

1. The "Wise" Brain Also Loves Shortcuts (Cognitive Biases)

Our brains are wired to "conserve energy" and naturally prefer shortcuts, known in psychology as cognitive biases. The wise are not immune.

• Confirmation Bias: This is the most common one. Simply put, we are more likely to believe information that aligns with our existing beliefs and automatically dismiss information that doesn't.
  • Example: A highly successful investor is very bullish on a particular industry. If a positive rumor about that industry surfaces, even if it's full of holes, he might believe it because "it confirms my judgment." Conversely, he might instinctively dismiss negative news as "fake news."

2. Too Much Information, Not Enough Time or Energy to Verify

We live in an age of information explosion. The sheer volume of information we encounter daily is staggering. Wise people are also human; their energy is finite.

• Verification Cost is Too High: Faced with a rumor that "seems plausible," thoroughly verifying it could take hours of research, source-checking, and cross-referencing. Most of the time, we simply don't have that time.
  • Analogy: Even the most skilled chef can't test every single cabbage in the market for pesticide residue. He has to rely on experience and trust. When a rumor is packaged professionally enough and its source appears sufficiently "authoritative," even the wise can be fooled.

3. Rumors Attack Emotion, Not Reason

Many sophisticated rumors don't appeal to logic; they directly manipulate your emotions. Once emotions take over, reason often goes "offline."

• Exploiting Fear, Anger, Sympathy:
  • "Don't eat XX food anymore, it causes cancer!" (Exploits fear)
  • "Look what they did, it's so unfair!" (Stirs anger)
  • "This child is so pitiful, share to support him!" (Evokes sympathy)
• Wise people also have strong emotions in areas they care about. For instance, a respected professor seeing a rumor like "Unscrupulous company pollutes water source, causing illness in hundreds of children" might believe it due to strong social responsibility and sympathy, quickly sharing it because emotional judgment overrides rational analysis.

4. "Everyone in My Circle is Saying It" (Social Pressure & Information Echo Chambers)

Humans are social creatures. We naturally care about the opinions of those around us, especially people we respect and trust.

• Information Echo Chamber: Wise people also have their own social circles, like academic or business circles. If a rumor spreads widely within this circle, and many respected friends or colleagues are discussing it, you unconsciously lower your guard.
  • Scenario: In a group chat of top scientists, someone shares a "groundbreaking study" packaged very professionally. Even if the study has flaws, because the sharers are leading figures in the field, people might assume its credibility. Few would publicly question it, challenging the group consensus.

5. Knowledge "Blind Spots" and "Arrogance" (The Wise Person's Dilemma)

The "wisdom" of the "wise" is usually confined to specific domains. An expert in one field might be a novice in another.

• Knowledge Blind Spots: A PhD in physics doesn't mean he understands finance; a history professor might not discern medical misinformation. When a rumor touches their blind spot, their judgment tools fail.
• Intellectual Arrogance: Sometimes, success in one field creates an illusion of "knowing everything." This confidence (even arrogance) can make them lower their guard when encountering information from unfamiliar domains. They are more likely to rely on intuition or existing logic to judge, rather than humbly verifying.

---

To Summarize

So, you see, "wise" people being deceived by rumors isn't because they are "not smart enough," but because:

1. They are human, with the same brain mechanisms and emotional needs as anyone else.
2. Their energy is limited; they cannot verify all information.
3. Their knowledge has boundaries; they cannot be omniscient.
4. They also live in society and are influenced by their circles and relationships.

The true meaning of "Rumors stop with the wise" might not be that the wise are immune to all rumors, but that a wise person will be more vigilant against these cognitive traps, more willing to reflect and verify, and have the courage to admit they can be wrong. This is perhaps the true essence of "wisdom."