Is surgical removal of tophi necessary?

Kristen Fisher
Kristen Fisher

Hey, regarding whether to undergo surgery for gouty tophi, I'd like to share my thoughts, hoping they can help you.

You can imagine gouty tophi as "crystals" of uric acid salts. When uric acid levels in the body are too high and cannot be excreted, over time, they deposit in your joints, soft tissues, or ears, forming hard lumps.

So, should they be removed? Simply put, not all gouty tophi require surgical removal, it depends on the situation.

When would a doctor recommend surgery?

  1. Impacts daily life: For example, if the tophi grow too large or are located in awkward places, such as finger or toe joints, making joint movement difficult, or even causing pain when wearing shoes, severely affecting your normal life and work.
  2. About to rupture, or already ruptured: Some tophi can thin the skin, appearing on the verge of rupturing. Or they have already ruptured, discharging a substance resembling toothpaste or tofu dregs. This situation is quite dangerous because the wound is difficult to heal and highly susceptible to infection. Once infected, the consequences can be very serious.
  3. Compresses nerves: If the tophi are located in a spot that compresses important nerves, causing numbness in your hands or feet, or severe pain, surgery might be necessary to relieve the compression.
  4. Cosmetic concerns: This is more subjective. If the tophi are in very noticeable areas like the face or ears, causing you embarrassment and psychological distress, surgical removal can also be considered.

When can surgery be postponed?

If your tophi are still relatively small, painless, and don't affect your mobility, then conservative medical treatment is usually the first choice.

In essence, this means strictly taking uric acid-lowering medications (such as febuxostat, allopurinol, etc.). The root cause of gouty tophi is high uric acid. As long as you can consistently control your blood uric acid levels to a very low level through medication (generally required to be below 300 μmol/L), these already formed tophi can slowly dissolve, shrink, and even completely disappear.

This is like a "melting ice" process. As your body's uric acid levels decrease, these "uric acid ice cubes" naturally won't be able to stay, and will gradually melt away. However, this process is slow and requires patience; it might take half a year, a year, or even longer of consistent medication to see significant results.

To summarize my advice:

  • Surgery is like "treating the symptoms"; it can quickly remove an obstructive tophus, but it cannot cure your hyperuricemia. If you remove one today, but your uric acid levels remain high, another might form elsewhere tomorrow.
  • Medication is "treating the root cause"; although slow, it addresses the problem at its source, preventing new tophi from forming and allowing existing ones to slowly dissolve.

Therefore, the best approach is to consult a rheumatologist for a comprehensive evaluation. Let the doctor assess the extent of your gouty tophi and, considering your overall health, discuss the most suitable treatment plan for you. Don't speculate on your own, and don't rush into surgery without proper consultation.