What is a 'Second Wine' from Bordeaux Châteaux? Is it Worth Buying?

What is a "Second Wine" from Bordeaux Châteaux?

Hey there! As someone who's enjoyed Bordeaux reds for several years, let me break this down for you. The "Second Wine" (also called Second Vin) from Bordeaux châteaux is essentially the estate's "second-in-command" wine. Simply put, when making wine each year, the château selects the absolute best grapes and wine lots to create their "Grand Vin" (like Lafite's flagship wine) – these are super expensive and top-tier in quality.

The remaining grapes, while not quite perfect (maybe slightly less ripe or from younger vines), are still very good. The château vinifies these into their Second Wine. Second Wines usually have different names, like Lafite's Carruades de Lafite. It's not inferior plonk, but rather a "streamlined version" of the château's style – tasting similar to the Grand Vin but often softer, more approachable, and significantly more affordable, typically 1/3 to 1/2 the price of the Grand Vin.

Why do they exist? Mainly to maintain the Grand Vin's high quality and reputation while not wasting good grapes. Major châteaux like Margaux and Latour all have their Second Wines, and some even have "Third Wines" now.

Is it Worth Buying?

Absolutely! Especially if you're an enthusiast like me, not rolling in cash. Second Wines offer incredible value for money, letting you experience the style and craftsmanship of a great château for relatively less. For example, a bottle of Château Lafite Rothschild Grand Vin might cost tens of thousands, but its Second Wine, Carruades de Lafite, can be had for a few thousand. It offers similar flavor profiles and is perfect for everyday drinking or as an introduction.

Of course, it depends on your situation:

• If you're on a budget: Highly recommended! It's miles better than generic supermarket wine and won't disappoint.
• If you seek the absolute pinnacle: The Grand Vin is still better, but a Second Wine is great for "testing the waters" – try the Second Wine first to see if you like the style before splurging on the Grand Vin.
• Buying tips: Opt for Second Wines from renowned châteaux, like Mouton Rothschild's Le Petit Mouton or Haut-Brion's La Chapelle de la Mission Haut-Brion. Choose better vintages (like the excellent 2010 or 2015), buy from reputable sources, and avoid suspiciously cheap deals (fakes exist!). In short, Second Wines are the "smart choice" in the Bordeaux world – I buy them often myself, finding them enjoyable without breaking the bank! Got any specific châteaux you're curious about? Let me know.