Why were older neural tissue vaccines (e.g., sheep brain vaccine) phased out?

Here's the translation of the provided content into English, maintaining the original structure and using natural language:

Hi, that's an excellent question. This actually involves an important chapter in medical progress.

Succinctly put, the core reason traditional neural tissue vaccines (like the sheep brain vaccine you mentioned) were phased out boils down to two words: unsafe. They carried a risk of causing severe, even fatal, neurological side effects.

---

What was the problem? "Kills 100 enemies but loses 800 of its own"

Let's break this down in simpler terms.

1. The old vaccines were produced using primitive methods Technology was limited back then. The method for making rabies vaccines was somewhat crude: the rabies virus was first injected into an animal (like a sheep or rabbit) brain. After the animal developed the disease, its brain tissue, packed with the virus, was harvested. This tissue was processed to inactivate the virus and then made into a vaccine.

2. The body's "friendly fire" When this vaccine is injected into your body, you're not only introducing inactivated rabies virus (which is what we want) – you're also injecting large amounts of animal neural tissue components (like myelin protein, the insulating sheath around nerves).

   This is where the problem lies! Your immune system gets the command: "Identify and attack this foreign stuff!" So, while it learns to recognize the rabies virus, it also mistakes "sheep neural tissue" for the enemy.

   The trouble is, sheep nerve tissue and human nerve tissue look somewhat similar. The immune system can get "face-blind." After attacking the sheep brain components in the vaccine, it turns around, sees your own nervous system, and thinks: "Hey, this looks familiar, just like that enemy! Attack it too!"

   This triggers an attack on your own central nervous system, causing a sort of "civil war." This is known as Post-vaccinal Allergic Encephalomyelitis (PAE).

This side effect is no joke. It could lead to:

• Severe headache, high fever
• Paralysis
• Seizures, coma
• Even death

Data at the time showed that the risk of serious neurological complications from such vaccines ranged from one in several hundred to one in several thousand. By today's standards, this risk was completely unacceptable. Back then, however, it was a case of choosing the lesser evil – rabies meant 100% mortality, while the vaccine, though risky, offered a fighting chance against certain death.

An analogy: Training security guards

Think of it like training a security guard (your immune system) to recognize one specific bad guy (the rabies virus).

• Old sheep brain vaccine: You show the guard a very blurry picture, featuring both the bad guy and your own family members mixed in. Result: The guard arrests the criminal but might also mistakenly attack your family.
• Modern vaccine: You give the guard a clear, solo photo of the bad guy. The guard recognizes him perfectly and targets only him, preventing friendly fire.

The new vaccine's "precision strike"

Advances in technology led to cell culture techniques.

Modern rabies vaccines (like the Human Diploid Cell Vaccine - HDCV or Vero Cell Vaccine) are made by growing the virus in laboratory cell cultures in dishes. The virus is then separated, highly purified, and inactivated.

This vaccine contains almost exclusively the "rabies virus antigens" we want the immune system to recognize, without the animal neural components that trigger the "civil war." Therefore, its safety is extremely high. Side effects are greatly reduced, typically limited to injection site reactions like redness, swelling, or soreness, or possibly a mild fever – normal immune reactions entirely different from those fatal neurological side effects.

Comparison: Old vs. New Rabies Vaccines

To summarize

Therefore, the phasing out of vaccines like the sheep brain vaccine was an inevitable consequence of medical progress. We moved from an option chosen out of necessity – "risk-laden but lifesaving" – to the optimal choice: "safe and highly effective." This marks a milestone not only in vaccine development history but also a major victory for public health in safeguarding human lives.