On the use of information asymmetry: In the film, this asymmetry is the core driver of the story's tragedy. Key conflicts often arise from the subtle dynamic of 'I know who you are, but you don't know that I know.' How does this narrative device contribute to building suspense?

Mechanisms of Information Asymmetry and Suspense Generation

1. Dual Awareness through "Dramatic Irony"

   • When the audience or specific characters possess additional information, the plot naturally forms "two cognitive tracks"—the informed versus the uninformed.
   • This triggers classic dramatic irony: characters walk blithely along an invisible cliff edge while the audience perceives the peril, heightening anxiety and anticipation.

2. Core Tension: "I Know Who You Are, But You Don’t Know I Know"

   • Information asymmetry is not static but a "latent advantage." The informed can strike at any moment; the uninformed risk exposure at every turn.
   • This imbalance transforms every conversation and glance into a potential "moment of exposure," turning mundane scenes into high-stakes confrontations.

3. Time Delay Creates "Prolonged Tension"

   • When the audience foresees a crisis but must wait for characters to discover the truth, a "temporal tug-of-war" emerges.
   • Protracted revelation stretches psychological tension, allowing suspense to intensify.

---

Exemplary Application in Infernal Affairs

---

Integrated Impact on Suspense, Conflict, and Tragedy

1. Maximized Suspense

   • Information asymmetry makes "revelation" the narrative’s most valuable currency.
   • Writers strategically deploy partial leaks, misdirection, and twists to distribute audience curiosity and anxiety across plot points.

2. Escalated Conflict

   • The informed act with calculated caution, embedding threats in dialogue; the uninformed inadvertently heighten risks.
   • Mutual provocation escalates conflict until it spirals beyond control.

3. Amplified Tragedy

   • Asymmetry creates "delayed destiny"—truth often surfaces alongside death or collapse.
   • Characters struggle despite inevitable doom, deepening their tragedy and evoking greater empathy.

4. Thematic Depth

   • "Infernal Affairs" (Avīci, the eighth great hell in Buddhism) embodies a cycle of suffering with "no exit, only endless torment."
   • Information asymmetry traps characters in "identity duality" and "moral gray zones," highlighting themes of fate and redemption.

---

Audience Psychological Effects

• Empathy-Anxiety Overload: Audiences sympathize with deceived characters while fearing for secret-keepers.
• Moral Engagement: Asymmetry prompts constant value judgments—"What would I do in their shoes?"
• Cathartic Release: Truth’s unveiling unleashes pent-up tension, delivering intense viewing satisfaction.

---

Summary

"I know who you are, but you don’t know I know" is a precision lever for suspense.
By crafting cognitive gaps, delaying revelations, and amplifying risks, Infernal Affairs transforms identity deception into an inescapable vortex of tragedy. Audiences endure anxiety and anticipation alongside characters until truth and fate collide, completing a narrative trinity of suspense, conflict, and tragedy.

One of the most captivating narrative features of Infernal Affairs is its masterful use of information asymmetry. This is not only the core driving force behind the story's tragedy but also the key technique for creating intense suspense. The subtle state of "I know who you are, but you don't know that I know" within the film is precisely the source of this suspense.

Specifically, this design contributes to building suspense in the following ways:

1. Creating Dramatic Irony:

   • From the outset, the audience possesses the "omniscient perspective," knowing that Chan Wing Yan (Tony Leung Chiu-wai) is an undercover police officer, while Lau Kin Ming (Andy Lau Tak-wah) is a triad mole. This informational advantage allows the audience to foresee potential conflicts and dangers while watching the characters interact.
   • When Chan Wing Yan and Lau Kin Ming meet in scenes like the hi-fi shop, the police station, or on the rooftop, the audience is fully aware of their true identities, while the characters themselves operate under information asymmetry. The tension of "I know something you don't know" infuses every conversation and every exchanged glance with undercurrents. The audience constantly wonders: When will they discover each other's secret? Who will be exposed first? This pre-established tension is the cornerstone of the suspense.

2. Building Psychological Warfare and Heart-Stopping Tension:

   • The core conflict of the film is not a simple battle between good and evil, but a psychological chess game between the two protagonists under the pressures of identity and survival. Lau Kin Ming knows Chan Wing Yan is an undercover cop and needs to find and eliminate him to cleanse his own record; Chan Wing Yan, later on, gradually uncovers Lau Kin Ming's true identity and needs to expose him to complete his mission.
   • This state of "I know who you are, but you don't know that I know" places both sides in a state of high alert and constant probing. Every phone call, every meeting could be the spark that reveals the truth. The audience is drawn into this vortex of psychological warfare, holding their breath with every move the characters make, fearing a single misstep could lead to utter ruin. This "heart-stopping" experience significantly amplifies the film's suspense.

3. Intensifying a Sense of Inevitability and Tragedy:

   • Information asymmetry not only creates immediate suspense but also imbues the story with a powerful sense of inevitability. The audience knows that under such an information gap, the fates of the two protagonists are inevitably tragic. Chan Wing Yan's undercover identity prevents him from returning to a normal life, while Lau Kin Ming's triad background ensures he can never truly become a "good man."
   • When Chan Wing Yan discovers on the rooftop that Lau Kin Ming is Hon Sam's mole, he gains crucial information, but Lau Kin Ming remains unaware that Chan Wing Yan knows. Precisely this information asymmetry leads to Chan Wing Yan's death – Lau Kin Ming must eliminate the person who knows his secret to protect himself. The lethality of this "I know something you don't know" dynamic pushes the suspense to its climax and ultimately detonates the tragedy. Witnessing the irreversible nature of fate within this suspense deepens the film's tragic tone.

4. Enhancing Narrative Layers and Complexity:

   • The film avoids simple linear storytelling. Instead, it constructs a complex narrative web through multiple layers of information asymmetry. Beyond the core asymmetry between Chan Wing Yan and Lau Kin Ming, there is the information warfare between Superintendent Wong Chi Shing and Hon Sam, as well as the police force's ignorance of Chan Wing Yan's true identity.
   • These multi-layered information gaps fill the story with variables and uncertainty. The audience must constantly piece together information and speculate about the next development. This intellectual engagement further heightens the appeal of the suspense.

In summary, Infernal Affairs successfully creates sustained dramatic irony, tense psychological warfare, and a profound sense of inevitability through its ingenious design of "I know who you are, but you don't know that I know." This masterful use of information asymmetry allows the film's suspense to build progressively, ultimately driving the story towards its poignant tragic conclusion.