How Should Defensive Investors Respond to Market Volatility?

Here is the translation of the provided content into English, maintaining the original Markdown format and ensuring natural, accurate English expression:

Okay, this question really hits at the heart of what every investor aiming for long-term, steady growth grapples with. As an avid reader of Graham, I'll share my understanding and personal approach, aiming to explain it in plain language.

How Should Defensive Investors Respond to Market Volatility?

Friend, we first need to be crystal clear about one thing: as defensive investors, our primary goal is not chasing short-term windfalls, but "not losing money" and "achieving satisfactory returns." Therefore, our entire strategy framework is built around this core principle.

Market volatility is ever-present, as natural as sunny and rainy weather. What we shouldn't do is try to predict when it will rain. Instead, we prepare a sturdy (maybe even hail-proof) umbrella before stepping out.

Below, I'll break down this "umbrella" into specific, actionable guidelines. Easy to grasp.

1. Build the Foundation: The Unshakeable Asset Allocation

This is absolutely the most important point, bar none. Before buying anything, figure out how you'll divide your money. Graham's classic advice for the defensive investor is:

Maintain a roughly 50/50 split between stocks and bonds.

You can fine-tune this ratio slightly between 25% and 75% based on your personal risk tolerance, but this 50/50 is an excellent starting point.

Why is this critical?

It's like installing a "shock absorber" for your portfolio. When the market crashes and the stock portion shrinks, your high-quality bonds (like Treasuries) typically remain stable, or may even rise due to a "flight to safety." This cushions the overall decline in your assets, keeping your emotions in check. When prices fall, you have money (bonds) to shift into stocks; when they rise, you have stocks you can shift into bonds. It automates "buying low and selling high."

Simply put: One part of your portfolio is for offense (stocks), and another part is for defense (bonds). So when things get rough, something's got your back.

2. Buy Cheap: Adhere Rigorously to the "Margin of Safety" Principle

"Margin of Safety" is the soul of Graham's investment philosophy.

Put simply: Pay 40 cents for something worth $1.

How to grasp this? A good company's intrinsic value might be $100 per share. But due to market panic, the price drops to $60. That $40 difference is your "Margin of Safety."

How does this help during volatility?

Provides a Downside Buffer: Even if the panic worsens and the price drops further to $50, you know it's still far below the $100 intrinsic value. You won't panic because your purchase price itself provides a huge protective cushion.
Provides Room for Error: If you misjudge and the company's true value is only $80 instead of $100, you're still safe since you bought at $60.

Therefore, defensive investors only buy when the price is significantly below intrinsic value. The more panicked and volatile the market, the more often these "bargains" appear.

3. Treat "Mr. Market" as Your Servant, Not Your Guide

Graham created a brilliant metaphor: "Mr. Market."

Imagine having a highly emotionally unstable business partner named "Mr. Market":

He visits you daily, offering a price at which he will either buy your share of the assets or sell you his.
When extremely optimistic (bull market), he quotes ridiculously high prices, wanting to buy out your shares.
When extremely pessimistic (bear market), he's terrified, offering absurdly low prices, begging you to buy his shares.

What should you do?

When he offers too high a price, consider selling him some of your shares to lock in profits.
When he offers too low a price, seize the chance to buy shares from him cheaply!
If his quote makes no sense, just ignore him; let him have his tantrum.

The key point: The power to trade rests with you. Market volatility is just "Mr. Market" throwing a fit. You don't need to join his panic or euphoria. Your job is to use his emotional swings to create favorable trades for yourself.

4. Maintain Discipline: Dollar-Cost Averaging (Systematic Investing)

This is a powerful weapon against human weaknesses and market turbulence.

The method is simple: Regardless of whether the market is rising or falling, you invest a fixed amount of money at regular intervals (like every payday).

What's the benefit?

Automatically enables "buying more when prices are low, less when high": When the market falls, the same money buys more shares; when it rises, it buys fewer shares. Over time, your average cost basis remains relatively low.
Overcomes the urge to time the market: You stop wrestling with impossible questions like "Is this the bottom?" or "Should I buy now?" You just execute your plan.

It's like setting your investments on "autopilot," keeping you on course through rough seas.

5. Tune Out the Noise: Focus on Business Fundamentals, Not Price Fluctuations

When you own a stock, remember: You own a piece of a business, not just a ticker symbol.

When the market plummets and your stock drops from $100 to $70, ask yourself:

Is the company's product still selling?
Is it still profitable? Is its competitive advantage ("moat") intact?
Did the stock fall due to a fundamental problem with the company itself, or simply because the whole market is panicking?

If the business itself is still sound, then the price drop is actually good news – "Mr. Market" is selling a good company at a discount. You should be pleased, not fearful.

To Summarize

So, the internal process of a mature defensive investor facing market volatility should look like this:

"Ah, the market's jumping around again. Let me check my portfolio: Hmm, the 50% in bonds is solid as a rock, giving me plenty of peace of mind. The stock part has dropped a fair bit... good chance to see if any companies I've had my eye on have fallen below their 'Margin of Safety.' If yes, I can use the money from dollar-cost averaging or shift some bonds into stocks to buy them. If not, I'll do nothing... go back to reading, drinking tea, and focusing on my job, waiting for next month's scheduled buy. After all, my portfolio is built for the next 10, 20 years. This little turbulence means nothing."

Ultimately, the essence of defensive investing is this: Through careful preparation and strict discipline up front, you turn market volatility from a "risk" into an "opportunity." Our profits don't come from predicting the market, but from profiting from the market's mistakes.